Nuclear: when one white elephant collapses, build another

nuclear powerIt is almost incredible, but true, that the Government can build a MOX (mixed oxide) plant at Sellafield costing £1.5bn which lamentably and comprehensively fails to meet its manufacturing targets and therefore has to be closed down, yet then is determined against all the odds to build another one at a cost of £2-3bn.

These were criticisms which I and many other critics on the outside levelled against the MOX scheme, but which both ministers and the nuclear industry ignored and belittled. However an FOI request last month has now uncovered that the BIS Department and its ministers privately agreed with our assessment of the high cost, low efficiency and poor effectiveness of the plant. This internal official assessment confirmed that the projected annual throughput was 120te, but SMP (the Sellafield Mox plant) actually manufactured just 13.8te of MOX fuelthroughout its whole 11-year operating life.

Continue reading

Tories about to build biggest white elephant

The government is shortly set to announce its decision to go ahead with building a second Sellafield MOX plant (SMP) at a cost of £3bn. MOX is a mixed uranium-plutonium oxide used as a nuclear reactor fuel.

The history of the first MOX plant, which was forced to close down several years ago, make this decision almost unbelievable. The fist plant cost £490m, plus £113m because of the falsification of the pellet data discovered in Japan, plus £100m decommissioning costs – total £700m. For this cost at taxpayers’ expense it was publicly announced that it would produce 120 tonnes of MOX per year. Continue reading