Were I still a Trotskyist, my position on the Scottish independence referendum would be determined by this set of questions:
- As America’s lapdog, key prop of international neoliberalism, meddler in foreign affairs, and cheerleader for market fundamentalism within the EU; would an independent Scotland severely diminish the UK’s influence?
- What are the social character of the movements backing Yes and No? Do they have the potential to mobilise wider layers of people, deepen radicalisation, and/or lead to a more opportune environment for socialist politics?
- Will the labour movement be strengthened by a victory for Yes or No?
- Will capital be strengthened by a victory for Yes or No?
But is that what has led the principal organisations of British Trotskyism to their positions? Continue reading