Means-testing winter fuel payments is another Labour own goal

Ed-Balls-008Ed Balls didn’t have to say it. It will save a piffling amount of money relative to the size of the budget deficit which is still plateaued at £122bn. Inasmuch as it’s a Tory-style policy, it’s doing the Tories’ dirty work for them. And it’s another nail (admittedly not the first or the only one) in the coffin of universalism. So why did Balls do it?

The Blairites at the PLP commended it on the grounds that it showed that Labour was quite capable of taking ‘tough’ decisions! As though trying to out-tory the Tories will bring the voters flocking in, or as though pre-empting what the Tories were probably going to do anyway (since it’s already been talked about extensively in Tory circles) is really smart politics. The honest truth is it just confirms that the toxic New Labour brand is still there in the Labour Party and that the view already widely held, that there’s really not much difference between the two parties, is right. Continue reading →

Universalism and Tory small state ideology

The Tory attack on universal benefits this weekend is part of an ongoing ideological assault on the public sector, dressed up as an attempt to cut the deficit through the destructive austerity program.

Iain Duncan Smith’s attempt to play down the story today is clever, but the proposal is out there and the narrative set.

The reported call on wealthier pensioners to pay back entitlements they don’t need is simply the latest step in the Conservatives consistent plan to reduce state spending and the welfare state. Continue reading →

What’s the welfare state without universalism?

A few weeks ago, Jon Cruddas appeared on Newsnight to float a number of policy ideas mostly related to the future of the Welfare State. On the whole there was little to give comfort to the millions of people suffering from brutal Tory austerity – the take home line was “foodbanks are here to stay”.

The most radical of Cruddas’ suggested was a fundamental challenge to the Welfare State as we know it. To me (at least), the basic social contract in this country has been that everyone contributes to a Welfare State according to their ability to pay and then everyone has access to the support they need in times of hardship.

Continue reading →