Peter Willsman reports from Labour’s November executive 

Willsman1National Executive Committee 22 November 2016 (‘Away Day’)

After several very tense and fractious set-tos there was clearly an effort made to have a tranquil NEC for a change. There was nothing faintly controversial on the agenda. The whole ‘Away Day’ was reminiscent of one of the Maharishi meditation sessions. Before reporting on the 22nd November NEC, there are two other meetings to quickly cover first.

National Policy Forum Report, 19-20th November

First, a brief report of the National Policy Forum (NPF) at Loughborough University, 19th and 20th November. The NPF was also calm and studious, as delegates hurried to workshops based around the 8 new Policy Commissions: Continue reading →

Labour Conference 2016: The good, the bad and the ugly

Watson & CorbynThe Good
Jeremy Corbyn’s victory was announced on the Saturday, with an increased vote from 59.5% to 61.8%. While the result was long expected, and came as a surprise to no-one except the Smith campaigners briefing he would win the week before, it should be underlined how significant this was. Over 313,209 people voted for Jeremy Corbyn, including most members in Europe’s largest left-of-centre party.

Continue reading →

Wednesday’s Yellow Pages at Labour Party Conference 2016

yellowpageswed28sept2016Download the Yellow Pages here. This Campaign Briefing is sponsored by CWU.

Let’s hear from the PLP 

Jeremy’s victory on Saturday meant that Conference started on a high for most of us. It was noticeable (especially at the rostrum!) that there were many delegates and visitors who were experiencing our Party’s sovereign body for the first time. They are eager to learn. This created a sense of excitement. Many policy seminars were quite well attended, as were many training sessions and, of course, fringe meetings were lively and well attended. CLPD had some 250 at both our fringes. Last year our meetings were, not surprisingly, somewhat euphoric. This year the participants were more focussed. There was also a determination to achieve some worthwhile change in our Party and in society in general.

Party members are wanting to engage and are looking for ideas and direction, so that we can take the fight to the Tories. It was recognised that this requires all of us to have a commitment to a considerable degree of unity. At the same time it was recognised that we are developing a coherent and effective pol- icy programme. As we saw throughout Conference, Jeremy is energetically responding to party members’ enthusiasm – as, for example, in the ten pledges setting out the framework for Labour’s campaign and a Labour Government. This frame- work will be the basis for policy making at the National Policy Forum. Conference was told that it was intend- ed to hold a full NPF within the next few months. The NEC will examine ways to give more power and influence to party members and to reform party structures accordingly.

At Conference CLPD also made progress with its party democracy agenda. The victory on Tuesday of the Sheffield Heeley rule change was par- ticularly noteworthy: future Annual Conferences will be able to vote in parts on documents, without having to accept them on a take-it-or-leave-it basis. The many rule changes put forward at the last minute by the NEC were something of a curate’s egg. But the fact that the sitting leader will automatically be on the ballot paper in future leadership elections was particularly wel- come, as was the agreement to have an effective women’s conference with a direct input into party policy making.

There was also a down side to Conference. Despite the many calls for party unity, it was not clear that the Party’s “moderate” wing is taking this seriously. At the NEC we saw an attempt to railroad through a fundamental change in the Party’s structure. It seems clear that this was essentially the “moderate” wing attempting to control two further seats on the NEC, in response to the progressive wing’s gaining two CLP seats. The putting together of 15 disparate rule changes into a “package” and then having one vote on the whole lot is not only unprecedented in the UK labour movement, but also throughout Europe.

Yet again the hard right Labour First caucus held its rally in an upstairs room of a pub. Thus allowing them to claim their meeting was “packed and over- flowing”. Some 20 years ago Yellow Pages shared its pitch outside Conference with productions from Labour First. It is notable that this year the hard right ideologues have returned. This was very much a mixed blessing.

During the week Jeremy continually emphasised his commitment to building party unity. Many delegates stressed that this required a similar commitment from the PLP, for example an ending to the undermining of our party Leader. There are some positive signs that the PLP are taking this seriously. It was cer- tainly clear that Conference is committed to this objective. Jeremy is clearly up for it, let’s hear from the PLP!

CLP delegates given the brush off by Cllr Gary Heather, Islington 

First, a delegate informed Conference that NEC members had told him that the NEC had not agreed that Conference should vote on all of their rule changes as a package. The delegate then asked the CAC Chair if this was the case, but his question was ignored. Another delegate made the point that reference backs moved by delegates on points related to the CAC report should be voted upon individually and not as a package. Again, this point was dismissed by the CAC Chair without providing any justification. The 2016 Conference Delegates’ Report states very clearly that a “part of a report” can be referred back to the CAC. Delegates do not have to accept or reject the entire CAC report.

To make matters worse, when the delegate called for a card vote the Conference Chair would not allow it. This is a blatant deviation from party rules. The Delegates’ Report specifies that “votes will be by a show of hands unless a delegate requests a card vote.” The delegate’s request should have been respected. It would certainly aid conference democracy if there was better guidance for delegates on how conference works and proper conference standing orders.

A delegate’s view by Richard Price, Leyton & Wanstead CLP

As a veteran of trade union conferences going back to the 1980s, but a first time delegate to Labour Conference, the first thing that strikes me is that, despite gaining an ongoing verbal commitment to “4+4”, this is still not a genuine working conference. Just two delegates from the floor were allowed to contribute on Composites 1-4, rendering real debate almost meaningless. There is also a serious democratic deficit. At crucial points on Sunday, Monday and Tuesday, the CAC and the platform ensured that grassroots democracy was extinguished, whether it was the spurious ruling out of order of the East Devon rule change, the unconstitutional refusal of card votes and the insistence that the dog’s breakfast of a “package” of NEC rule changes had to be taken as one vote.

Throughout Conference, there were heartfelt calls for unity and stern lectures that without power none of our great aims can be achieved. But the sense I got from the Progress/Labour First wing of the Party is that civil war will be ongoing, that they don’t accept the validity of Jeremy’s second landslide mandate, and that they will fight, fight and fight again to preserve the Party from socialism. The most surreal moment? The sight of a section of delegates wildly cheering in favour of nuclear weapons.

The Saga of East Devon (Part 1) 

Having only just rested after her seven hour journey up from East Devon, the delegate was stunned to hear that the CAC had binned her CLP’s much needed rule change. This seeks to give constituency branches & TU branches the right to interview and nominate candidates ahead of the parliamentary long list. The CAC had been rewriting party history by claiming that the Collins Review was a constitutional amendment – when instead it was a conference report and thus completely irrelevant to the 3-year-rule. Most folk would have been left devastatingly demoralised and gone off for a pint in the Baltic Fleet… but not the East Devon delegate! Her indefatigability shone through as she took to the rostrum on Sunday morn- ing, the minute after the CAC had moved their first report. Delegate after delegate echoed her campaign for justice, democracy but above all due process! The Chair of the CAC refused to take a separate vote on the issue, but instead invited the East Devon delegate to meet the CAC…

The Saga of East Devon (Part 2) 

The East Devon delegate went up and down the escalator like a Weston donkey throughout Sunday afternoon and yesterday morning, hoping to track down the CAC. It wasn’t until just before the end of conference yesterday that the delegate managed to scrape an appointment. At the start of this meeting, the Chair of the CAC informed the East Devon delegate that the final deci- sion had already been made, and that her fellow delegates would indeed be denied the chance even to read her CLP’s modest proposal. Despite this, the delegate gave an impas- sioned yet precise case as to why those in the conference hall should be given their right to hear this rule change. She was 100% correct in the fact that the 3-year-rule makes no reference whatsoever to conference reports such as the Collins review.

Yesterday at the NEC

  • Dennis Skinner is retiring from the NEC at the end of Conference and was given a standing ovation. Dennis responded by giving one of his impromptu and rousing speeches.
  • The new NEC Chair is Glenis Wilmott, Leader of the Labour Group of MEPs. Andy Kerr of CWU is the new Vice Chair.

Tuesday’s Yellow Pages at Labour Party Conference 2016

yellowpagestuesday270916Download the Yellow Pages here. This Campaign Briefing is sponsored by Unite.

TSSA Emergency Motion: Support Reference Back! 

TSSA has submitted an emergency motion about the package of rule changes the NEC is putting to Conference today. The key proposals in the TSSA emergency are set out below. It has been ruled out of order by the CAC on grounds that are not clear. The CAC will report their action to Conference this morning. The raft of 15 rule changes from the NEC that is being rail-roaded through Conference on one single card vote is totally unprecedented. It is difficult to avoid the conclusion that this is little other than factionalism – this only three days after Jeremy’s victory and appeals throughout the Party to come together. The TSSA emergency spells out a way of proceeding based on discussion and consen-sus.

  • Please support TSSA’s reference back. We need to build a more democratic party together.
  • If the TSSA emergency motion is unsuccessful –Vote against the stitch up!

The TSSA motion addresses the CAC’s recommendation that the NEC party reform proposals be considered and voted on as a single item. It calls for these proposals to be considered along- side other party reform proposals from the Party Reform working groups and from TULO. It calls on the NEC to convene a special meeting to consider all proposals and then to convene a special conference. It seeks to ensure a balanced set of changes are made that unites the Party around a new settlement and ensures women, black and minority ethnic groups, disabled, LGBT and young people can organise effectively.

National Constitutional Committee, vote Chris Williamson 

We need people on the NCC who will deal fairly and justly with all discipli- nary cases referred to the NCC.
Make sure you go straight to the ballot area first thing this morning and collect your ballot paper. Already this week there have been reports of single delegates collecting ballot papers and voting before other CLP delegates arrive. This will ensure constituen- cy mandates are respected. Don’t lose out – make sure you get the ballot paper first.

NEC: all smoke and mirrors

Sunday’s CAC Report 1 contained the statement that “the NEC agreed a package of rule changes at its meeting yesterday, which will be voted on as a single item.” At Monday’s NEC, several members objected to this statement, saying the NEC had certainly not agreed to one card vote on all 15 of the (mostly unrelated) rule changes set out in the Appendix to CAC Report 1.

The rule changes are a very mixed bag, including issues relat- ing to affiliations to CLP AGMs; a national annual women’s confer- ence; probity of Labour Combined Authority Mayors & Police Commissioners; annual levy to the party by Labour Group members; NEC seats for Leaders of the Scottish & Welsh Parties; eight TU members of the TULO Contact Group being able to attend Clause V meetings and Scottish & Welsh ECs to be responsible for adminis- trating the selection of PPCs.

In response to the objections, it was argued that the Refounding Labour document had been put as one package to Conference a few years ago. It was then pointed out that this was a coherent group of proposals and involved only one or two rule changes, whereas today we have a dazzling kaleidoscope of subjects. It was further pointed out that this bizarre procedure is not only unprecedented at Annual Conference, but must surely be unprecedented anywhere in the labour movement.

This point was endorsed by the most senior NEC member, who was very worried, in terms of proce- dure, that we were moving into totally unchartered waters. At the end of the debate the Chair of the NEC resolved that a vote should not be taken at the NEC and he turned to next business. The senior NEC member then raised a procedural point – namely that this bizarre procedure must not be accepted as a precedent of any sort and that in future, rule changes should be considered separately. The NEC Chair accepted this point and asked for it to be minuted.

CAC Report: East Devon’s Final Push! Support Reference Back! 

First thing this morning, the East Devon delegate will take the rostrum once again in a final push for due process and party democracy. Their brilliant yet long overdue rule change will allow constituency & TU branches to interview & nominate candidates ahead of the parliamentary long list. She has been challenging the CAC for quoting the 3-year-rule, pointing out this rule should only be invoked fol- lowing a constitutional amendment. It makes no reference whatsoever to a conference report, such as the Collins Review. Support the East Devon delegate in her campaign to give Conference the right to hear the motion on conference floor.

Rule changes: support more say for members! 

Today Conference will debate rule changes (also known as constitutional amendments). Please support:

  • Sheffield Heeley
    • The change being proposed by Sheffield Heeley CLP would enable Conference delegates to amend documents from Policy Commissions when they get to Conference. The original Partnership in Power documents prom- ised that Conference would be able to amend documents – but it has never happened. “Take it or leave it” documents have been the bugbear of the National Policy Forum process. Democratise the NPF – support the Sheffield Heeley rule change!
  • Mid-Norfolk (+6 others)
    • Delegates have the opportunity to change the rules to allow CLPs, trade unions and Socialist Societies to submit BOTH a rule change AND a contemporary motion. To suggest this would unleash a torrent of rule changes is ludicrous! CLPs and affiliates should not have to choose – support the rule change from Mid-Norfolk and six other CLPs!
  • Bury North
    • This rule change would cement the intention of the rules and ensure that there should be at least four contemporary resolution priorities selected for debate at conference by BOTH CLPs AND affiliates – eight in total. Support Bury North!

Breath of fresh air on Trade Deals, By Len McCluskey General Secretary, Unite

The NEC Statement on International Trade marks a welcome step change in our Party’s thinking on the new generation trade deals. TTIP, CETA and TiSA are free trade treaties that have at their heart the locking in of irreversible privatisation and the de-regulation of employment and human rights and environmental and occupational health and safety standards. This privatisation and de-regulation will be protected by a system of quasi- courts open only to multinational corporations that will give the corporate sector the right to sue governments that legislate in the interests of the 99% at the expense of the 1%.

The European Commission and Canada are in a mad scramble to get the CETA treaty signed as soon as possible – they claim they have reformed away the problem issues, but nothing could be further from the truth. They claim they will protect workers’ rights, but experience shows that unions in Latin America have had to campaign for seven years to get a hearing. Changing the name of the corporate courts from ISDS to ICS should not fool us – these courts will not give citizens or unions the right to challenge the multinationals. TTIP, CETA and TiSA will not allow us to “take back control” – they will hand sovereignty to the corporate sector.

A new direction is needed. We took the first step in this new direction when Labour MPs won the point in the Queen’s Speech debate to keep the NHS out of TTIP. The NEC Statement takes us further: it allows our Party to stand with millions of our fellow citizens across Europe who have exposed and cam- paigned against TTIP and CETA.