Why the means justifies the means (say Gordon Brown and Wile E Coyote)

Wile_E_CoyoteChuck Jones, the creator of Daffy Duck, Bugs Bunny and a host of other great cartoon characters once explained that the inspiration for his Wile E. Coyote character (all his efforts to capture Road Runner fail but he never ceases to work on his ineffective plans) was a remark of the philosopher George Santayana who said “A fanatic is one who redoubles his effort when he has forgotten his aim”.

I am reminded of this quotation when I hear Labour Party politicians dismissing debate about deep long-term radical change as an indulgence on the grounds that nothing can be done without winning power which must therefore be the governing aim. My Labour MP recently told the General Committee of the Constituency Party “the core purpose of the Labour Party” is  “to help us win elections”. Note, “the core purpose”. The core purpose is not, it seems, to develop a clear view of the sort of society we want to create (apart from a few platitudes about fairness and inequality”). Such a long-term view is virtually never discussed in the Labour Party. Instead the focus is on a programme that is slim enough and untroubling enough to ruffle as few feathers as possible. In other words trying to establish Labour as ‘not the Tories’ but without being so different that “middle England” might get nervous. Continue reading

Brown has a nerve to lecture us on economic credibility or winning elections

Gordon Brown at the NPF 2008It is hard to believe that Brown had the gall in his anti-Corbyn diatribe to declare that “the best way of realising our high ideals is to show that we have an alternative in government that is…neither a pale imitation of what the Tories offer nor is the route to being a party of permanent protest, rather than a party of government”. The prime reason that Labour lost 5 million votes between 1997 and 2010 was, apart from Iraq, the fact that a very large minority of Labour voters did think precisely that – that under the regimes of Blair and Brown Labour was indeed ‘a pale imitation of what the Tories offer’. It’s also why UKIP gained 4 million votes at the election three months ago because a huge chunk of the electorate had indeed come to the conclusion that ‘they’re all the same’. Continue reading

Gordon Brown and power

Has Gordon Brown reGordon Brown and patriotic Labourached down from heaven and, like the vengeful Presbyterian God, smited Jeremy Corbyn with his great clunking fist? Well, no. The much-trailed Power with a Purpose speech wasn’t the knock out some were hoping for, as if a talk could derail the Jeremy juggernaut anyway. Instead we had a thoughtful, nuanced and lengthy tour of the policy and ethics of the Labour Party. He asked the questions about what Labour is, its purpose, its direction of travel. In a way, it was less an attack on Corbyn – though one can easily be found in the historical vistas Gordon directs us to. In fact, the nearest he comes to explicitly doing so is in the following: Continue reading

Socialism not nationalism is what should govern the life of Scotland, says Gordon

From each according to his ability to contribute; to each according to his needs. That is the best principle that can govern the life of our country today.”

Thus Gordon Brown, at last and at his best, put socialism firmly at the heart of the reason to vote No in the Scottish referendum. It should have happened sooner. There never should have been a Better Together campaign. Labour and the Tories are better apart. Labour is (or should be) a socialist, internationalist party committed to democracy and solidarity not “unionism”. Continue reading

10 really good things about Gordon Brown

Gordon Brown , copyright World Economic ForumIt’s true that for a number of years you couldn’t put a fag paper between the politics of Tony Blair and Gordon Brown, and though we all heaved a sigh of relief when he eventually took over, he did disappoint us as PM. But Gordon has many great strengths and, just at this moment, there isn’t a better person to try to save the day for class politics in Scotland and the rest of Britain. And here are ten really good things about him: Continue reading