Searching for socialism in the New York mayoral primary

Bill de BlasioPrimaries, primaries. All this talk of bringing in a public vote to decide Labour’s next candidate for London mayor, and we can easily forget that another large, multicultural city is routinely going through the process of primary selection right now. Bill de Blasio is now in the lead in the selection of the Democrats’ candidate for mayor of New York, although it is still unclear as to whether his margin of victory is wide enough to avoid a run-off vote. He has promised affordable housing, used the rhetoric of the occupy movement and been arrested on a demo against hospital closures, when other mayoral hopefuls hung back. The writer Naomi Klein re-tweeted a community organiser’s observation that de Blasio “ran as an unabashed populist”.

I’ve been in New York for over a week, and I haven’t made a trip to my local high street in East Williamsburg, Brooklyn, without being told I should vote for someone or other. Round here, there’s less focus on the mayoral race – primary selections also took place yesterday for the many districts of the New York city council. Humberto Soto is all the rage on Grand Street. His smiles look sincere enough in the windows of delis and hair salons, but all I can find out about him from the internet is that he raised $4,480. Still only enough for him to garner 5.5 per cent of the vote. Poor Humberto.

Continue reading →

Campaign to oppose primaries

Primaries model motionThe Labour Party is calling on its members to let its leaders know by Friday 13 September what they think about Ed Miliband’s proposals on “building a better Labour Party, so we can build a better Britain.”

Tell us how you’d build a better Labour Party – a party that is rooted in the hopes of the British people, that reaches out to every community in the country, that has members and candidates from every walk of life.

The Campaign for Labour Party Democracy has produced a draft motion which you may wish to use as a basis for a response by your constituency party, members branch or trade union branch on the introduction of primaries: Continue reading →

Dangers of the Collins review

Defend the Link  full colourJust two years away from the General Election, the priorities of the Labour Party ought to be obvious. These surely need to be to strengthen our campaign against the Coalition government’s failing policies; sharpen our alternatives in anticipation of government; and preparing our internal organisation for the elections in 2014 and 2015. Yet for some reason, we’re plunging into an internal conflict over a central element of our Constitution. Continue reading →

The battle for the heart of Labour and why Ed might struggle to mobilise support

Red heartEd Miliband has announced some sweeping changes in the political and financial relationship between the Labour party and its affiliated trade unions. These have, so far, only been sketched out and we await to see what precise form (in terms of rule changes) they will take. The anticipated reforms include:

  1. A shift from collective to individual affiliation to the party: in future trade union members would make an individual choice to join the party rather than being automatically affiliated through the decision of their union executives and conferences.
  2. Limits to the amount of money aspiring candidates can spend in selection contests.
  3. New limits on outside earnings by MPs and new rules on conflict of interests too.
  4. The selection of candidates for the London mayoralty and for parliament by primaries in which all party sympathisers and not simply members would be entitled to vote. Continue reading →

Ed Miliband – guilty not of Blairism but of wishful thinking

Miliband thinkingWhen they joined the party, most Labour members had a belief that they would have some influence in their party. But under the Blairites, power was centralised and members were patronised.

In the future, in the mooted new model party being cobbled together, individual members would be expected to pay some £45, work hard and yet have no more influence on key decisions such as primaries than someone who registers as a “supporter” at the last minute and pays nothing.

Ed Miliband sees primaries as a way of re-energising the party. Wishful thinking. As we see in the United States, success in primaries is the preserve of the rich. If they were used in parliamentary selections, we’d have even fewer working class MPs than we have now. But individual members might well choose to have their vote and save their £45. They wouldn’t lose much influence! Continue reading →