Latest post on Left Futures

Punishing young people financially is the Tory way

carrot and stickThe idea of giving young people aged 18-21 guaranteed access to education or training or help to find work is obviously a good one, but why spoil it by proposing that such persons should receive a means-tested ‘youth allowance’ at a rate perhaps even lower that the current job seeker’s allowance (JSA)?

JSA is already paid at the extremely low level of £72.40 a week (£10.34 a day) for adults aged over 25 – almost the lowest rate of unemployment benefit anywhere in Europe – and for those aged below 25 the rate actually falls to no more than £57.35 a week (£8.19 a day). It is now proposed in the IPPR report published on Thursday that they will only get this princely bauble if they already had the skills to secure a job or were in vocational training.

A successful training policy depends on three principles.

1. Growth

One is an economic policy that favours growth over continued downward pressure on economic demand (i.e. prologed austerity) so that there widespread opportunities for well-paid, high-skilled, high-productivity jobs. Today there are still 2.3 million people unemployed who can’t find such jobs since they are scarcely available. Of the 1.5 million jobs the government boasts it has created, two-thirds are in self-employment on a pittance income and the overwhelming majority of the remainder are in low-paid, insecure or zero hours contracts jobs.

2. Quality training

The second requirement is good-quality trainers, not the likes of A4E or Serco who cherry-pick the most able or motivated young people to get the government’s bounty, but focus much less on others who thereby lose not only job opportunities by work benefits as well.

3. Incentive

The third requirement is a positive programme that fires up young people’s enthusiasm, not one super-charged with sanctions.

Why does Labour so often follow the Tory line whilst tweaking it a bit to remove the rough insensitivities, but still sticking to the same Tory principles?

Why have we accepted the Tory policy of austerity for reducing the budget deficit when growth would do the job far quicker?

Why have we gone along with the Tory canard that people on unemployment benefit are all skivers or shirkers when they desperately want a good job, but it’s not available when there are 4 times more people on the dole than there are job vacancies available?

Why have we fallen for the ugly Tory practice of sanctioning people (i.e. depriving them of all benefits) even for the slightest offence when the number of deliberate miscreants is tiny and the real problem is the system’s failure to offer the sufficient incentives?

Image copyright: ajt / 123RF Stock Photo


  1. PoundInYourPocket says:

    Why ?
    Because Labour has mutated into the Tory party.
    Good night and goodbye…

  2. Robert says:

    What a choice Cameron’s conservatives and the labour party Progress Tory Lite.

    One Nation is one nation of the rich and god when I listen to Miliband the bloke speaks sadly like the rich well off middle class he is.

  3. Rod says:

    If you don’t like Labour’s Tory/Progress policies don’t policies, don’t vote Labour.

    It’s the only way to bring Labour’s elite to their senses.

  4. David Melvin says:

    Labour is now the Progress faction. Miliband’ s main supporters are Progress favourites Reeves, Umunna and Hunt. Miliband is merely their front man. I resigned from the Labour party in January, but recently had an email from the CLP forwarding an invite to a Progress conference offering a years free membership for attendees.

    1. Robert says:

      I resigned in 2010 and have just been invited to stand for office in the local party.

      I still get the labour parties news letter and have been invited to tea coffee and meetings, because I’m in a trade Union member they think I’m labour because according to labour all trade Unionists are labour.

      1. Rod says:

        My LP membership expired a couple of months ago.

        The Progress clowns won’t be getting anything out of me ever again.

        I’d happily vote Labour but the Tory/Progress entryists who run the Labour Party today are not Labour.

        Stuff ’em.

        1. Robert says:

          I think most working class people are the same hence Labour are chasing the Tory swing voters.

© 2024 Left Futures | Powered by WordPress | theme originated from PrimePress by Ravi Varma